A typology of reviews: an analysis of 14 review types and associated methodologies.
By M. Grant, Andrew Booth. Health Information and Libraries Journal, 2009
9,360 citations recorded by the source corpus.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES The expansion of evidence-based practice across sectors has lead to an increasing variety of review types. However, the diversity of terminology used means that the full potential of these review types may be lost amongst a confusion of indistinct and misapplied terms. The objective of this study is to provide descriptive insight into the most common types of reviews, with illustrative examples from health and health information domains. METHODS Following scoping searches, an examination was made of the vocabulary associated with the literature of review and synthesis (literary warrant). A simple analytical framework -- Search, AppraisaL, Synthesis and Analysis (SALSA) -- was used to examine the main review types. RESULTS Fourteen review types and associated methodologies were analysed against the SALSA framework, illustrating the inputs and processes of each review type. A description of the key characteristics is given, together with perceived strengths and weaknesses. A limited number of review types are currently utilized within the health information domain. CONCLUSIONS Few review types possess prescribed and explicit methodologies and many fall short of being mutually exclusive. Notwithstanding such limitations, this typology provides a valuable reference point for those commissioning, conducting, supporting or interpreting reviews, both within health information and the wider health care domain.
Subfields: General Health Professions, Statistics and Probability
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/bd5b9c8ef53bc8ff29441a0aa832851171c211bf
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In General Health Professions
- Ulla Kinnunen *
- T. Feldt
- Anne Mäkikangas
- Arnold B. Bakker
- Guy Paré
- Andrea C. Tricco
- Wilmar B. Schaufeli
- Z. Munn
In Statistics and Probability
Citations in the corpus
- A Framework for Guiding and Evaluating Literature Reviews (2015, neutral): “…scholars have discussed methodological issues related to research synthesis and proposed dimensions along which to distinguish between types of literature reviews (e.g., Cooper, 1988; Gough, Thomas, & Oliver, 2012; Grant & Booth, 2009; King & He, 2005; Paré et al., 2012; Rousseau et al., 2008).”
- Consumer demand for time of use electricity tariffs: A systematized review of the empirical evidence (2018, background): “This paper presents the design and results of a systematized literature review [12] aimed at answering five main review questions:”
- The person-oriented approach to burnout: A systematic review (2016, methodology): “A systematic qualitative review urthermore permits the inclusion of different kinds of studies, nlike for example, a meta-analysis which only allows the inclusion f similar studies (Grant & Booth, 2009).”
- Method for conducting systematic literature review and meta-analysis for environmental science research (2019, methodology): “From those common review method types, this article authors associated Protocol and Reporting result with Search, Appraisal, Synthesis, and Analysis framework, and develop (PSALSAR) framework.”
- Assessment in mathematics education: responding to issues regarding methodology, policy, and equity (2018, positive): “Our review might be termed a state-of-the-art review, according to the categorisation of Grant and Booth (2009), who state that such reviews “tend to address more current matters in contrast to other combined retrospective and current approaches.”
- Cochrane Rapid Reviews Methods Group offers evidence-informed guidance to conduct rapid reviews (2020, neutral): “Although published descriptions of RRs date back nearly a decade [6,7], a standard or consensus definition does not exist.”
- An overview of the features of chatbots in mental health: A scoping review (2019, background): “It is well known that scoping reviews are different from systematic reviews in having broader topics and including studies with more diverse study designs [26, 27].”
- The State of Makerspace Research: a Review of the Literature (2020, background): “Grant & Booth (2009) describe this type of literature review as an overview, “a summary of the literature that attempts to survey the literature and describe its characteristics” (p. 94).”
- Scoping reviews: the PAGER framework for improving the quality of reporting (2021, methodology): “At the same time, scoping reviews offer a more systematised and transparent method to identify and analyse all the relevant literature than narrative reviews where the selection and analysis of literature is often less systematic and comprehensive (Grant & Booth, 2009).”
- Thinking through and designing qualitative research studies: a focused mapping review of 30 years of qualitative research in sport psychology (2019, methodology): “Mayan (2009) argued that if the researcher’s position does not fit with the research question, the rigour of the study is compromised. For example, a sport psychology study examining athletes’ experiences in sport conducted from a constructionist philosophical position (with relativist ontological a”