Race, Ideology, and Academic Ability: A Relational Analysis of Racial Narratives in Mathematics

By Niral Shah. Teachers College Record, 2017

124 citations recorded by the source corpus.

Background/Context There is evidence that race affects students’ learning experiences in mathematics, a subject typically thought of as “race-neutral” and “culture-free.” Research in psychology and sociology has shown that racial narratives (e.g., “Asians are good at math”) are pervasive in U.S. culture and play a critical role in shaping people's lived experiences. However, racial narratives have received little explicit attention in the mathematics education literature. Purpose The purpose of this study was to examine the racial ideological context of mathematics education, specifically in terms of how students made sense of racial narratives about academic ability. Participants Thirty-five students identifying as Asian, Black or African American, Latinx, Polynesian, White, and mixed race were interviewed. These students were recruited from four mathematics classrooms observed by the author at a racially diverse high school in Northern California. Research Design This qualitative study employed an ethnographic research design to gather data on the meanings students constructed around issues of race in the context of mathematics. Data Collection and Analysis A semistructured interview protocol was used to conduct individual interviews with each student participant. Field notes were taken during 130 hours of participant observation over the course of a school year. Interview transcripts and field notes were analyzed for instances in which participants invoked racial narratives. Each of these narratives was first coded by topic and by the racial group to which the narrative referred. Narrative clusters were then identified and analyzed in order to understand how the narratives were related to each other. Findings Students invoked a variety of racial narratives about both mathematical and nonmathematical topics (e.g., athletic ability, general intelligence, parenting practices). Importantly, students did not invoke these narratives in isolation. Instead, nearly all of these narratives were invoked in conjunction with at least one other narrative. This relationality among racial narratives shows how the academic abilities of learners from diverse racial backgrounds are constructed in relation to each other, often in ways that position non-Asian students of color as inferior in mathematics. Conclusions/Recommendations This article suggests the need for study designs and analytical approaches that theorize race as a relational construct that transcends the Black-White paradigm. Further, this article challenges researchers and practitioners to reconsider boundaries between what is deemed “mathematical” and “nonmathematical” in classroom discourse, specifically with respect to sociopolitical phenomena like race. Two African American boys, Will and Derrick, wait patiently as their math teacher circulates the room. She is passing back the results of the latest math test. Will receives his grade: He earned an ‘A.’ Derrick sees Will's grade and exclaims: “Oh you're hecka smart in math! You must have some Asian in you!”

Subfields: Education, Sociology and Political Science

View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/8c46cbadb5ef2a1aa9a580dd2603afc53d2c9308

How researchers see this paper

The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.

In Education

  1. Nicole Louie
  2. D. Martin
  3. Ebony O. McGee
  4. Luis A. Leyva
  5. Rochelle Gutiérrez
  6. Niral Shah
  7. David Stinson
  8. Gregory V. Larnell

In Sociology and Political Science

  1. Nicole Louie
  2. D. Martin
  3. Ebony O. McGee
  4. Luis A. Leyva
  5. Rochelle Gutiérrez
  6. Niral Shah
  7. J. Matthews

Citations in the corpus