Systematic review or scoping review? Guidance for authors when choosing between a systematic or scoping review approach
By Z. Munn, M. Peters, Cindy Stern, Catalin Tufanaru, A. McArthur, E. Aromataris. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2018
9,506 citations recorded by the source corpus.
BackgroundScoping reviews are a relatively new approach to evidence synthesis and currently there exists little guidance regarding the decision to choose between a systematic review or scoping review approach when synthesising evidence. The purpose of this article is to clearly describe the differences in indications between scoping reviews and systematic reviews and to provide guidance for when a scoping review is (and is not) appropriate.ResultsResearchers may conduct scoping reviews instead of systematic reviews where the purpose of the review is to identify knowledge gaps, scope a body of literature, clarify concepts or to investigate research conduct. While useful in their own right, scoping reviews may also be helpful precursors to systematic reviews and can be used to confirm the relevance of inclusion criteria and potential questions.ConclusionsScoping reviews are a useful tool in the ever increasing arsenal of evidence synthesis approaches. Although conducted for different purposes compared to systematic reviews, scoping reviews still require rigorous and transparent methods in their conduct to ensure that the results are trustworthy. Our hope is that with clear guidance available regarding whether to conduct a scoping review or a systematic review, there will be less scoping reviews being performed for inappropriate indications better served by a systematic review, and vice-versa.
Subfields: General Health Professions, Sociology and Political Science, Statistics and Probability
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/3a15c1b8f79039ea17fd151e7457f7199af25259
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In General Health Professions
- M. Peters
- Andrea C. Tricco
- Ikhlaas Gurrib
- Firuz Kamalov
- David Santandreu Calonge
- C. Godfrey
- P. McInerney
- Lara N. Wolfers
In Sociology and Political Science
- Lara N. Wolfers
- C. Bradbury‐Jones
- M. Peters
- Andrea C. Tricco
- R. Hunter
- Kevin Harris
- Julie Taylor
- M. Beattie
In Statistics and Probability
- M. Peters
- Lara N. Wolfers
- H. Khalil
- Andrea C. Tricco
- R. Hunter
- Kevin Harris
- M. Beattie
- Frank M. Schneider
Citations in the corpus
- Best practice guidance and reporting items for the development of scoping review protocols (2022, positive): “18 The task of screening and selecting sources to include from search results can be time consuming and unreliable without clearly articulated criteria.”
- New Era of Artificial Intelligence in Education: Towards a Sustainable Multifaceted Revolution (2023, methodology): “It serves as an effective tool for determining the overall scope and coverage of the existing literature on a particular topic (in the context of this study, an investigation of the effect of AI on education by examining its applications, advantages, and challenges), providing a clear indication of ”
- Understanding Eco-anxiety: A Systematic Scoping Review of Current Literature and Identified Knowledge Gaps (2021, background): “clarify key concepts and definitions, and inform a later systematic review [14] as well”
- Practical and ethical challenges of large language models in education: A systematic scoping review (2023, methodology): “A systematic scoping review was conducted in this study as this method has been frequently used in emerging and rapidly evolving research areas to scope a body of literature and identify the key concepts, methods, evidence, and challenges (Munn et al., 2018).”
- Realist review (2021, background): “A scoping review is interested in discovering how much is known about a particular research area; what the key concepts are; and what type of research activity has taken place in the field (Munn et al., 2018).”
- Using Media for Coping: A Scoping Review (2020, methodology): “To address these questions, drawing on existing recommended steps (e.g., Munn et al., 2018; Peters et al., 2015) and guidelines for reporting (i.e., Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses [PRISMA]; Moher et al., 2009; Tricco et al., 2018), we conducted a scoping review…”
- Scoping reviews: the PAGER framework for improving the quality of reporting (2021, methodology): “Definitional clarity around the use, method and outcome of many reviews continues, despite efforts to present best practice around when and how, specific review methods are most appropriate (Munn et al., 2018).”
- Undertaking a scoping review: A practical guide for nursing and midwifery students, clinicians, researchers, and academics (2021, methodology): “There are several approaches for conducting evidence synthesis (Grant & Booth, 2009; Munn et al., 2018).”
- Updated methodological guidance for the conduct of scoping reviews (2020, background): “Broadly speaking, if the intention of the review is to inform clinical decision-making (eg, determining the feasibility, appropriateness, meaningfulness, or effectiveness of a particular intervention), then a systematic review is more appropriate.(21) Scoping reviews, however, are more appropriate t”