The faculty of language: what's special about it?
By Steven Pinker, Ray Jackendoff. Cognition, 2005
1,094 citations recorded by the source corpus.
We examine the question of which aspects of language are uniquely human and uniquely linguistic in light of recent suggestions by Hauser, Chomsky, and Fitch that the only such aspect is syntactic recursion, the rest of language being either specific to humans but not to language (e.g. words and concepts) or not specific to humans (e.g. speech perception). We find the hypothesis problematic. It ignores the many aspects of grammar that are not recursive, such as phonology, morphology, case, agreement, and many properties of words. It is inconsistent with the anatomy and neural control of the human vocal tract. And it is weakened by experiments suggesting that speech perception cannot be reduced to primate audition, that word learning cannot be reduced to fact learning, and that at least one gene involved in speech and language was evolutionarily selected in the human lineage but is not specific to recursion. The recursion-only claim, we suggest, is motivated by Chomsky's recent approach to syntax, the Minimalist Program, which de-emphasizes the same aspects of language. The approach, however, is sufficiently problematic that it cannot be used to support claims about evolution. We contest related arguments that language is not an adaptation, namely that it is "perfect," non-redundant, unusable in any partial form, and badly designed for communication. The hypothesis that language is a complex adaptation for communication which evolved piecemeal avoids all these problems.
Subfields: Cultural Studies, Developmental and Educational Psychology, Language and Linguistics
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/c6ce3e018ef17c598a8d2bb346ccc110d44e4abc
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Cultural Studies
- Morten H. Christiansen
- N. Chater
- Stephen C. Levinson
- Nicholas Evans
- Patricia K. Kuhl
- Barbara T. Conboy
- Denise Padden
- Tobey Nelson
In Developmental and Educational Psychology
- Patricia K. Kuhl
- Morten H. Christiansen
- Stephen C. Levinson
- N. Chater
- Barbara T. Conboy
- Denise Padden
- Tobey Nelson
- S. Coffey-Corina
In Language and Linguistics
- Morten H. Christiansen
- N. Chater
- Stephen C. Levinson
- Giosuè Baggio
- Nicholas Evans
- Patricia K. Kuhl
- Richard Granger
- W. Tecumseh Fitch
Citations in the corpus
- Language as shaped by the brain. (2008, background): “…et al. 2006), to the Simpler Syntax (SS) version of generative grammar proposed by Jackendoff (2002) and colleagues (Culicover & Jackendoff 2005; Pinker & Jackendoff 2005), to the Minimalist Program (MP) in which language acquisition is confined to learning a lexicon from which cross-linguistic…”
- Some thoughts on the contrastive analysis of features in second language acquisition (2009, background): “…is surely not to minimize the constraining role of UG in the representation of a (second) language, beyond that minimization already undertaken by the Minimalist Program in general (see Marantz, 1995; Chomsky, 2005; Fitch et al., 2005; and some counter-arguments in Pinker and Jackendoff, 2005).”
- Before and below ‘theory of mind’: embodied simulation and the neural correlates of social cognition (2007, background): “It should be emphasized that even critics of the 'recursion-only hypothesis' applauded the merit of abandoning a monolithic view of language (see Pinker & Jackendoff 2005).”
- Phonetic learning as a pathway to language: new data and native language magnet theory expanded (NLM-e) (2008, background): “How infants accomplish the task has become the focus of debate on the nature and origins of language (Hauser et al. 2002a; Kuhl 2004; Newport & Aslin 2004; Fitch et al. 2005; Pinker & Jackendoff 2005).”
- Semantics and the electrophysiology of meaning: Tense, aspect, event structure (2004, background): “But while these models account for how competence constrains performance [101], they seem to overlook the possibility that the reverse is also the case: aspects of linguistic structure may be the outcome of evolutionary processes leading to an adaptation of the brain to language use, that is to perf”
- The Phonological Loop (2010, background): “A different point of view claims that language can be seen as a biological adaptation showing species-specific features at all levels: phonological, syntactical, lexical, and semantic (Jackendoff and Pinker 2005; Pinker 1995; Pinker and Jackendoff 2005).”
- The myth of language universals: language diversity and its importance for cognitive science. (2009, background): “As far as structures are concerned, tail (or peripheral) recursion (sometimes hard to distinguish from mere iteration) is usefully differentiated from nested recursion or centre-embedding, which requires push-down stack memory (see Parker 2006; Pinker & Jackendoff 2005, p. 203).”
- Speech Perception (2004, background): “Some have argued that the categorical nature of phoneme perception (see section 3) shows that its objects are not ordinary sounds, since ordinary sounds need not be perceived categorically (for discussion, see, e.g., Trout, 2001; Pinker and Jackendoff, 2005; for a critical perspective, see, e.g., Di”
- The Evolution of Language: A Comparative Review (2005, background): “Crucially, this result weakens the scope of the ‘argument from design’ in language evolution (Pinker and Jackendoff 2005): when biased glossogenetic change is possible, a close fit between language and learners does not necessarily indicate a phylogenetic adaptation to communication or language.”
- The input–output relationship in first language acquisition (2006, background): “First, the exact definition of the Universal Grammar is still lacking (see Pinker & Jackendoff, 2005 ).”
- Engines of the Brain The Computational Instruction Set of Human Cognition (2006, background): “The basic algorithms that have been derived include many that are not typically included in proposed “primitive” or low-level sets: se-is consistent with a broad range of constraints that are argued to rule out alternative hypotheses (see, for example, Pinker 1999; Pinker and Jackendoff 2005).”