The Diversity–Innovation Paradox in Science
By Bas Hofstra, V. V. Kulkarni, Sebastian Munoz-Najar Galvez, Bryan He, Dan Jurafsky, Daniel A. McFarland. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2019
830 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Significance By analyzing data from nearly all US PhD recipients and their dissertations across three decades, this paper finds demographically underrepresented students innovate at higher rates than majority students, but their novel contributions are discounted and less likely to earn them academic positions. The discounting of minorities’ innovations may partly explain their underrepresentation in influential positions of academia. Prior work finds a diversity paradox: Diversity breeds innovation, yet underrepresented groups that diversify organizations have less successful careers within them. Does the diversity paradox hold for scientists as well? We study this by utilizing a near-complete population of ∼1.2 million US doctoral recipients from 1977 to 2015 and following their careers into publishing and faculty positions. We use text analysis and machine learning to answer a series of questions: How do we detect scientific innovations? Are underrepresented groups more likely to generate scientific innovations? And are the innovations of underrepresented groups adopted and rewarded? Our analyses show that underrepresented groups produce higher rates of scientific novelty. However, their novel contributions are devalued and discounted: For example, novel contributions by gender and racial minorities are taken up by other scholars at lower rates than novel contributions by gender and racial majorities, and equally impactful contributions of gender and racial minorities are less likely to result in successful scientific careers than for majority groups. These results suggest there may be unwarranted reproduction of stratification in academic careers that discounts diversity’s role in innovation and partly explains the underrepresentation of some groups in academia.
Subfields: General Social Sciences, Sociology and Political Science, Statistics and Probability
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/7324b1cd04274c683842edf883f71db5aff0536d
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Sociology and Political Science
- Nicole T. Buchanan
- Isis H. Settles
- Leah R. Warner
- Emma Pierson
- Daphna Shohamy
- D. Bassett
- Marzyeh Ghassemi
- Sherri Rose
In Statistics and Probability
- Nicole T. Buchanan
- Emma Pierson
- Daphna Shohamy
- D. Bassett
- Marzyeh Ghassemi
- Martinque K. Jones
- Shalmali Joshi
- Irene Y. Chen
Citations in the corpus
- Ethical Machine Learning in Healthcare (2020, background): “h shows that scientists from underrepresented racial and gender groups tend to prioritize dierent research topics. They produce more novel research, but their innovations are taken up at lower rates (47). Female scientists tend to study dierent scientic subelds, even within the same larger eld | for”
- Racial and ethnic imbalance in neuroscience reference lists and intersections with gender (2020, background): “Hence, the efforts to physically diversify the bodies we place in university offices must be complemented by efforts to mentally diversify the ideas and idea-makers that we engage with, cite, and place before our students in colloquia, syllabi, hallway portraiture, et cetera (71, 72).”
- Artificial intelligence and illusions of understanding in scientific research (2024, neutral): “In particular, although the contributions of scholars from minority groups tend to be more innovative, they receive less uptake from fellow scientists 122,167,168 .”
- Understanding psychology's resistance to intersectionality theory using a framework of epistemic exclusion and invisibility (2020, positive): “Novel scientific questions and research findings by women and Black, Indigenous, and other people of color are discounted, devalued, and underutilized by dominant scholars compared to innovations by white men (Hofstra et al., 2020).”