The evolution of the language faculty: clarifications and implications.
By W. Tecumseh Fitch, Marc D. Hauser, Noam Chomsky. 2005
610 citations recorded by the source corpus.
In this response to Pinker and Jackendoff's critique, we extend our previous framework for discussion of language evolution, clarifying certain distinctions and elaborating on a number of points. In the first half of the paper, we reiterate that profitable research into the biology and evolution of language requires fractionation of "language" into component mechanisms and interfaces, a non-trivial endeavor whose results are unlikely to map onto traditional disciplinary boundaries. Our terminological distinction between FLN and FLB is intended to help clarify misunderstandings and aid interdisciplinary rapprochement. By blurring this distinction, Pinker and Jackendoff mischaracterize our hypothesis 3 which concerns only FLN, not "language" as a whole. Many of their arguments and examples are thus irrelevant to this hypothesis. Their critique of the minimalist program is for the most part equally irrelevant, because very few of the arguments in our original paper were tied to this program; in an online appendix we detail the deep inaccuracies in their characterization of this program. Concerning evolution, we believe that Pinker and Jackendoff's emphasis on the past adaptive history of the language faculty is misplaced. Such questions are unlikely to be resolved empirically due to a lack of relevant data, and invite speculation rather than research. Preoccupation with the issue has retarded progress in the field by diverting research away from empirical questions, many of which can be addressed with comparative data. Moreover, offering an adaptive hypothesis as an alternative to our hypothesis concerning mechanisms is a logical error, as questions of function are independent of those concerning mechanism. The second half of our paper consists of a detailed response to the specific data discussed by Pinker and Jackendoff. Although many of their examples are irrelevant to our original paper and arguments, we find several areas of substantive disagreement that could be resolved by future empirical research. We conclude that progress in understanding the evolution of language will require much more empirical research, grounded in modern comparative biology, more interdisciplinary collaboration, and much less of the adaptive storytelling and phylogenetic speculation that has traditionally characterized the field.
Subfields: Cultural Studies, Developmental Biology, Molecular Biology, Linguistics
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Cultural Studies
- Morten H. Christiansen
- N. Chater
- Stephen C. Levinson
- Nicholas Evans
- Ray Jackendoff
- Giosuè Baggio
- Donna Lardiere
- Surya Ganguli
In Developmental Biology
In Molecular Biology
- Ivo Danihelka
- Jascha Narain Sohl-Dickstein
- Morten H. Christiansen
- Alex Graves
- N. Chater
- Surya Ganguli
- Greg Wayne
- Yoav Goldberg
In Linguistics
- Morten H. Christiansen
- N. Chater
- Stephen C. Levinson
- Ray Jackendoff
- Nicholas Evans
- Mehran Sahami
- Steven Pinker
- J. Hulstijn
Citations in the corpus
- Neural Turing Machines (2014, background): “Historically, cognitive science and linguistics emerged as fields at roughly the same time as artificial intelligence, all deeply influenced by the advent of the computer (Chomsky, 1956) (Miller, 2003).”
- Some thoughts on the contrastive analysis of features in second language acquisition (2009, background): “…is surely not to minimize the constraining role of UG in the representation of a (second) language, beyond that minimization already undertaken by the Minimalist Program in general (see Marantz, 1995; Chomsky, 2005; Fitch et al., 2005; and some counter-arguments in Pinker and Jackendoff, 2005).”
- Language Proficiency in Native and Nonnative Speakers: An Agenda for Research and Suggestions for Second-Language Assessment (2011, background): “In recent publications, Chomsky has narrowed down Universal Grammar to the principle of recursivity and the operation of Merge, speculating about the genetic basis of this principle (Chomsky, 2007; Fitch, Hauser, & Chomsky, 2005).”
- The Phonological Loop (2010, background): “Some scholars (Fitch, Hauser, and Chomsky 2005; Hauser, Chomsky, and Fitch 2002), on the basis of the imperant structuralist perspective led by Noam Chomsky, claim that language contains several elements partly shared with other species, such as perceptual and motor ca- Francisco Aboitiz is…”
- The nature of the language faculty and its implications for evolution of language (Reply to Fitch, Hauser, and Chomsky) (2005, background): “In Pinker & Jackendoff (2005, henceforth PJ), we disputed the second and third suggestions; in Fitch, Hauser, and Chomsky (2005) (FHC), the authors respond to our critique.”
- The myth of language universals: language diversity and its importance for cognitive science. (2009, background): “Fitch et al. (2005) replied that “the putative absence of obvious recursion in one of these languages is no more relevant to the human ability to master recursion than the existence of three vowel languages calls into doubt the human ability to master a five- or ten-vowel language” (p. 203).”
- Language as shaped by the brain. (2008, background): “The exact nature of UG is controversial even among its proponents (e.g., Chomsky 1995; 2005b; 2006; Crain & Pietroski 2001; Fitch et al. 2005; Hauser et al. 2002; Jackendoff 2002; 2007; Lightfoot 1999) and critics point at the inadequacy of UG definitions (e.”
- Deep Knowledge Tracing (2015, background): “Two themes in the field of cognitive science that are particularly relevant are theories that the human mind, and its learning process, are recursive [12] and driven by analogy [13].”
- Semantics and the electrophysiology of meaning: Tense, aspect, event structure (2004, background): “However, they deny what functionalists on the contrary accept, namely that syntax is well-designed for use [24, 87, 54].”