The dark side

By G. Petsko. Genome Biology, 2000

724 citations recorded by the source corpus.

Francis Crick once said that if you can’t study function you had better study structure. He probably meant that studying function was hard but structure provided a powerful entry into the problem. But I like to think that he actually was giving us his version of “Once you start down that path, forever will it dominate your destiny,” advice given about the danger of the Dark Side of the Force, in the movie Star Wars: The Empire Strikes Back. For if there is a dark side to the structure/function relationship, it is to be found when we search for function. We will all face the dark side before long, as the emphasis in genomics shifts from identifying and sequencing genes to the problem of determining what their products do. Leaving aside the formidable technical challenges posed by that problem, there remains the prospect that the job, as commonly considered, is impossible: because the term ‘function’ means very different things to different people, and a given gene product might have almost as many ‘functions’ as there are scientists studying it. There is its biochemical function: the chemical or physical process it carries out when isolated from the cell and studied in vitro. There is its cellular function signal transduction protein, translation inhibitor, transcription factor, and so on-which may depend on its location in the cell, what other molecules it is bound to, when in the cell cycle it is expressed, and so on. Then there is its larger biological function, which is most often defined by the phenotype that is observed when it is deleted or mutated: growth control, or immune regulation, or involvement in morpho-genesis, to name but a few possibilities. The layers are almost infinite, especially for genes in metazoan organisms. Consider actin. Its biochemical function is to bind ATP and hydrolyse it, but it is not very good at that on its own. The ATPase activity can be modulated by the binding of other molecules-a common phenomenon in biochemistry. One could also say that the ‘real’ function of actin is to self-polymerize, forming filaments. This brings us closer to the cellular roles of actin, but these are legion: essential component of the cytoskeleton, ‘railroad track’ along which vesicles and other cellular constituents run, anchor for myosin in muscle contraction, target for the mushroom toxin phal-loidin, rigidifier of microvilli, backbone of the acrosome, inhibitor of DNase I, and many …

View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/d80b5a81b20d84c3fee7673551c28b51b25f5b3b

How researchers see this paper

The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.

  1. Gabriele Piccoli
  2. Blake Ives
  3. A. Powell
  4. Kevin Sean Chan
  5. Sibel Adali
  6. Zachary G. Baker
  7. Jin-Hee Cho
  8. A. LeRoy

Citations in the corpus