Spurious but systematic correlations in functional connectivity MRI networks arise from subject motion
By Jonathan D. Power, Kelly Anne Barnes, Abraham Z. Snyder, Bradley L. Schlaggar, Steven E. Petersen. NeuroImage, 2011
7,424 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Here, we demonstrate that subject motion produces substantial changes in the timecourses of resting state functional connectivity MRI (rs-fcMRI) data despite compensatory spatial registration and regression of motion estimates from the data. These changes cause systematic but spurious correlation structures throughout the brain. Specifically, many long-distance correlations are decreased by subject motion, whereas many short-distance correlations are increased. These changes in rs-fcMRI correlations do not arise from, nor are they adequately countered by, some common functional connectivity processing steps. Two indices of data quality are proposed, and a simple method to reduce motion-related effects in rs-fcMRI analyses is demonstrated that should be flexibly implementable across a variety of software platforms. We demonstrate how application of this technique impacts our own data, modifying previous conclusions about brain development. These results suggest the need for greater care in dealing with subject motion, and the need to critically revisit previous rs-fcMRI work that may not have adequately controlled for effects of transient subject movements.
Subfields: Cognitive Neuroscience, Radiology, Nuclear Medicine and Imaging
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/5d7e514d45141178fc1061bd18f1102d8318a8c3
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Cognitive Neuroscience
- Olaf Sporns
- Xi-Nian Zuo
- Stephen M. Smith
- D. Bassett
- Michael P. Milham
- Yong He
- Steven E. Petersen
- E. Bullmore
In Radiology, Nuclear Medicine and Imaging
- Olaf Sporns
- Stephen M. Smith
- Xi-Nian Zuo
- D. Bassett
- Steven E. Petersen
- Yong He
- Jonathan D. Power
- E. Bullmore
Citations in the corpus
- Resting state fMRI: A review of methods and clinical applications (2012, neutral): “correction for head motion can result in spurious correlations in RS-fMRI analysis.(30-32) Although head motion is less concerning”
- Evaluation of ICA-AROMA and alternative strategies for motion artifact removal in resting state fMRI (2015, methodology): “Power et al. (2012), or if they belonged to the 5% highest movers as determined by a motion summary score.”
- Using Dual Regression to Investigate Network Shape and Amplitude in Functional Connectivity Analyses (2017, methodology): “Many studies have shown that motion is a major source of variability in functional connectivity studies that can lead to erroneous results when comparing groups of subjects (Power et al., 2012; Satterthwaite et al., 2012; Van Dijk et al., 2012).”
- Statistical Improvements in Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Analyses Produced by Censoring High-Motion Data Points (2013, methodology): “This procedure revealed clear and powerful effects of motion in our RSFC analyses despite having prepared our data with standard motion regressions [Power et al., 2012].”
- Cognitive relevance of the community structure of the human brain functional coactivation network (2013, background): “There was no evidence for residual effects of head movement on these corrected regional mean time series (49)”
- Dynamic functional connectivity of the default mode network tracks daydreaming (2014, methodology): “Effects of motion on FC values can persist despite the performance of preprocessing steps similar to those used here (Power et al., 2012; Van Dijk et al., 2012), so here we used partial correlation to test whether mean motion, calculated as mean absolute displacement of each brain volume compared…”
- Human Connectome Project Informatics: quality control, database services, and data visualization (2013, methodology): “The DVARS QCmetric of the FUNCTIONAL_QC pipeline is appreciably higher than has been previously reported (Power et al., 2012) because it is calculated on time series acquired at higher spatial resolution, hence, containing an increased proportion of electronic noise that have undergone only motion c”
- Head motion during MRI acquisition reduces gray matter volume and thickness estimates (2015, neutral): “Twelve healthy adult volunteers (having given informed consent) were scanned on a 3T TIM Trio MRI system (Siemens Healthcare, Erlangen) using the vendorsupplied 12-channel head matrix coil supplied.”
- ICA-based artefact and accelerated fMRI acquisition for improved Resting State Network imaging (2014, background): “However, it has been shown (Power et al., 2012; Satterthwaite et al., 2013) that such approaches are often not capable of completely removing the effects of motion.”
- The UCLA multimodal connectivity database: a web-based platform for brain connectivity matrix sharing and analysis (2012, methodology): “…motion scrubbing to identify TRs with a relative motion displacement greater than 0.5 mm or a relative BOLD signal intensity change greater than 0.5% (Power et al., 2012), and (13) registered with FSL FLIRT to the MNI152 average brain with a 4 mm 3 voxel resolution in a three stage registration…”
- Questions and controversies in the study of time-varying functional connectivity in resting fMRI (2020, neutral): “Volume censoring (“scrubbing”; Power et al., 2012) is another commonly used method to minimize the effects of head motion on FC estimates.”
- Principal components of functional connectivity: A new approach to study dynamic brain connectivity during rest (2013, methodology): “…+ |Δγ| N 0.5, where the rotational displacements α,β,γwere converted tomillimeters by calculating the displacement on the surface of a sphere of radius 50 mm (Power et al., 2012), or 2) were considered as intensity spikes, defined as a whole-brain intensity of more than 2 standard deviations…”
- MRIQC: Advancing the automatic prediction of image quality in MRI from unseen sites (2016, background): “Image analysis can lead to erroneous conclusions when the original data are of low quality (e.g. [1–4]).”
- Mapping neurotransmitter systems to the structural and functional organization of the human neocortex (2021, methodology): “Functional MRI data were preprocessed using procedures designed to facilitate subsequent network exploration [90].”
- Methods to detect, characterize, and remove motion artifact in resting state fMRI (2013, methodology): “This measure indexes the movement of the head from one volume to the next, and is calculated as the sum of the absolute values of the differentiated realignment estimates (by backwards differences) at every timepoint (Power et al., 2012).”
- Benchmarking functional connectome‐based predictive models for resting‐state fMRI (2019, neutral): “The box displays the median and quartiles, while the whiskers give the 5 th and 95 th percentiles. global signal mean regression (Fox et al., 2009; Murphy et al., 2009; Power et al., 2012).”