Lazy, not biased: Susceptibility to partisan fake news is better explained by lack of reasoning than by motivated reasoning.
By Gordon Pennycook, David G. Rand. Cognition, 2019
1,665 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Why do people believe blatantly inaccurate news headlines ("fake news")? Do we use our reasoning abilities to convince ourselves that statements that align with our ideology are true, or does reasoning allow us to effectively differentiate fake from real regardless of political ideology? Here we test these competing accounts in two studies (total N = 3446 Mechanical Turk workers) by using the Cognitive Reflection Test (CRT) as a measure of the propensity to engage in analytical reasoning. We find that CRT performance is negatively correlated with the perceived accuracy of fake news, and positively correlated with the ability to discern fake news from real news - even for headlines that align with individuals' political ideology. Moreover, overall discernment was actually better for ideologically aligned headlines than for misaligned headlines. Finally, a headline-level analysis finds that CRT is negatively correlated with perceived accuracy of relatively implausible (primarily fake) headlines, and positively correlated with perceived accuracy of relatively plausible (primarily real) headlines. In contrast, the correlation between CRT and perceived accuracy is unrelated to how closely the headline aligns with the participant's ideology. Thus, we conclude that analytic thinking is used to assess the plausibility of headlines, regardless of whether the stories are consistent or inconsistent with one's political ideology. Our findings therefore suggest that susceptibility to fake news is driven more by lazy thinking than it is by partisan bias per se - a finding that opens potential avenues for fighting fake news.
Subfields: Communication, Literature and Literary Theory, Sociology and Political Science
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/81fe024b0903ea646249321c7912ed0255a0d2f9
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Communication
- S. van der Linden
- J. Roozenbeek
- Gordon Pennycook
- David G. Rand
- Nicholas C. Dias
- Thomas Nygren
- Brendan Nyhan
- Jabin Binnendyk
In Literature and Literary Theory
- S. van der Linden
- J. Roozenbeek
- Gordon Pennycook
- David G. Rand
- J. Pierre
- Nicholas C. Dias
- Thomas Nygren
- Sumitra Badrinathan
In Sociology and Political Science
- S. van der Linden
- J. Roozenbeek
- David G. Rand
- Gordon Pennycook
- Brendan Nyhan
- Nicholas C. Dias
- Sumitra Badrinathan
- Thomas Nygren
Citations in the corpus
- Prebunking interventions based on the psychological theory of “inoculation” can reduce susceptibility to misinformation across cultures. (2020, background): “The importance of education level and cognitive abilities has been noted as crucial to navigating online information in constructive ways (Nygren, 2019; Nygren & Guath, 2019; Pennycook & Rand, 2019).”
- Fighting COVID-19 Misinformation on Social Media: Experimental Evidence for a Scalable Accuracy-Nudge Intervention (2020, background): “…2017; Van Bavel & Pereira, 2018), our data are more consistent with recent studies on political misinformation that provide both correlational (Pennycook & Rand, 2019b; including data from Twitter sharing, Mosleh, Pennycook, Arechar, & Rand, 2020) and experimental (Bago, Rand, & Pennycook,…”
- The Implied Truth Effect: Attaching Warnings to a Subset of Fake News Headlines Increases Perceived Accuracy of Headlines Without Warnings (2020, background): “…that individuals who are more analytic and deliberative are less likely to believe politically concordant false news (Bronstein et al. 2019; Pennycook and Rand 2019b, c), rather than more likely according to the motivated cognition account (Kahan et al. 2012, Kahan 2017), and that insofar…”
- You are fake news: political bias in perceptions of fake news (2020, background): “These findings are in line with other recent research on fake news (Pennycook and Rand, 2019) and opinions polls which find that conservatives (45%) are substantially more likely than liberals (17%) to state that the mainstream media is regularly reporting fake news (Monmouth University, 2018).”
- Emphasizing publishers does not effectively reduce susceptibility to misinformation on social media (2020, methodology): “Yet, others (Austin & Dong, 1994, Pennycook & Rand, 2019b, Jakesch et al., 2018) have failed to demonstrate that assessments of news stories are changed by source information.”
- Durably reducing conspiracy beliefs through dialogues with AI (2024, neutral): “…align more closely with an alternative theoretical perspective that posits a central role for analytic thinking in protecting against epistemically suspect beliefs and behaviors ( 14 ), such as superstitions and paranormal beliefs ( 43 ), misinformation ( 44 ), and pseudo-profound bullshit ( 45 ).”
- Identity concerns drive belief: The impact of partisan identity on the belief and dissemination of true and false news (2018, background): “Although there are reasons to believe that conservatives are more credulous than liberals (Pennycook & Rand, 2018b; Sterling et al., 2016) because they usually have higher levels of need for closure (Jost et al., 2017), other work has found that liberals and conservatives can be equally biased…”
- Systematic Literature Review on the Spread of Health-related Misinformation on Social Media (2019, background): “In particular, there is a need to understand better the roles of both ideology and belief systems (Jost et al., 2018) and what might be termed "lazy thinking" (Pennycook and Rand, 2018) .”