Beyond Adoption: A New Framework for Theorizing and Evaluating Nonadoption, Abandonment, and Challenges to the Scale-Up, Spread, and Sustainability of Health and Care Technologies
By Trisha Greenhalgh, Joseph P. Wherton, Chrysanthi Papoutsi, J. Lynch, G. Hughes, C. A'Court, S. Hinder, N. Fahy, Rob Procter, S. Shaw. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 2017
2,221 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Background Many promising technological innovations in health and social care are characterized by nonadoption or abandonment by individuals or by failed attempts to scale up locally, spread distantly, or sustain the innovation long term at the organization or system level. Objective Our objective was to produce an evidence-based, theory-informed, and pragmatic framework to help predict and evaluate the success of a technology-supported health or social care program. Methods The study had 2 parallel components: (1) secondary research (hermeneutic systematic review) to identify key domains, and (2) empirical case studies of technology implementation to explore, test, and refine these domains. We studied 6 technology-supported programs—video outpatient consultations, global positioning system tracking for cognitive impairment, pendant alarm services, remote biomarker monitoring for heart failure, care organizing software, and integrated case management via data sharing—using longitudinal ethnography and action research for up to 3 years across more than 20 organizations. Data were collected at micro level (individual technology users), meso level (organizational processes and systems), and macro level (national policy and wider context). Analysis and synthesis was aided by sociotechnically informed theories of individual, organizational, and system change. The draft framework was shared with colleagues who were introducing or evaluating other technology-supported health or care programs and refined in response to feedback. Results The literature review identified 28 previous technology implementation frameworks, of which 14 had taken a dynamic systems approach (including 2 integrative reviews of previous work). Our empirical dataset consisted of over 400 hours of ethnographic observation, 165 semistructured interviews, and 200 documents. The final nonadoption, abandonment, scale-up, spread, and sustainability (NASSS) framework included questions in 7 domains: the condition or illness, the technology, the value proposition, the adopter system (comprising professional staff, patient, and lay caregivers), the organization(s), the wider (institutional and societal) context, and the interaction and mutual adaptation between all these domains over time. Our empirical case studies raised a variety of challenges across all 7 domains, each classified as simple (straightforward, predictable, few components), complicated (multiple interacting components or issues), or complex (dynamic, unpredictable, not easily disaggregated into constituent components). Programs characterized by complicatedness proved difficult but not impossible to implement. Those characterized by complexity in multiple NASSS domains rarely, if ever, became mainstreamed. The framework showed promise when applied (both prospectively and retrospectively) to other programs. Conclusions Subject to further empirical testing, NASSS could be applied across a range of technological innovations in health and social care. It has several potential uses: (1) to inform the design of a new technology; (2) to identify technological solutions that (perhaps despite policy or industry enthusiasm) have a limited chance of achieving large-scale, sustained adoption; (3) to plan the implementation, scale-up, or rollout of a technology program; and (4) to explain and learn from program failures.
Subfields: General Health Professions, Health Information Management, Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/22045a246f145c4c8414c4ce03b586a9445a441d
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In General Health Professions
- Chrysanthi Papoutsi
- Trevor Jamieson
- Trisha Greenhalgh
- James Shaw
- B. Chaney
- S. Reddy
- Frank Rudzicz
- Avi Goldfarb
In Health Information Management
In Public Health, Environmental and Occupational Health
Citations in the corpus
- Generative AI in healthcare: an implementation science informed translational path on application, integration and governance (2024, methodology): “The tech-nology’s maturity, reliability and ease of integration into existing systems are crucial factors affecting its adoption [58].”
- The Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence Conversational Agents in Health Care: Systematic Review (2020, background): “This is a pervasive issue in technological innovation, so much that it drove the development of the nonadoption, abandonment, scale-up, spread, and sustainability framework as a means of predicting and assessing the success of new health technologies [58] and the development and evaluation of new co”
- Preparing Workplaces for Digital Transformation: An Integrative Review and Framework of Multi-Level Factors (2021, methodology): “Additionally, we manually searched reference lists of reviews on digital transformation and relevant highly cited publications, and conducted “ancestry and snowballing” citation tracking (Greenhalgh et al., 2005, p. 5; Greenhalgh et al., 2017).”
- Analysing the role of complexity in explaining the fortunes of technology programmes: empirical application of the NASSS framework (2018, background): “This work both informed, and was informed by, our ongoing systematic review [16].”
- Digital Mental Health Interventions for Depression, Anxiety, and Enhancement of Psychological Well-Being Among College Students: Systematic Review (2018, positive): “The research-to-practice gap for digital mental health interventions is increasingly being recognized, and leaders in the field have proposed strategies to routinely incorporate implementation science methods into the study of digital mental health interventions [148,149].”
- Artificial Intelligence and the Implementation Challenge (2019, methodology): “The NASSS framework and other work in implementation science for digital health technologies emphasize the importance of attending to the particular value proposition that a new technology offers for health care stakeholders [8,9].”
- Evolving Role of Social Media in Health Promotion: Updated Responsibilities for Health Education Specialists (2020, methodology): “Moreover, HESPA II 2020 produced a new hierarchical model with eight areas of responsibility, 35 competencies, and 193 subcompetencies [13].”
- "The human body is a black box": supporting clinical decision-making with deep learning (2019, background): “Trish Greenhalgh’s “Nonadoption, Abandonment, Scale-up, Spread, and Sustainability” (NASSS) framework consists of 6 domains other than the technology at hand, including the wider political and regulatory system and organizational characteristics such as leadership and readiness for change [22].”
- Studying complexity in health services research: desperately seeking an overdue paradigm shift (2018, neutral): “Sustainability (NASSS) in organisations [25].”