Insights from measuring pollen deposition: quantifying the pre-eminence of bees as flower visitors and effective pollinators
By P. Willmer, H. Cunnold, G. Ballantyne. Arthropod-Plant Interactions, 2017
114 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Using our accumulated datasets from Kenyan savanna, Mediterranean garigue, UK gardens and heathland, involving 76 plants from 30 families, we present detailed data to quantify the superiority of bees as pollinators of most flowering plants when compared with other flower visitors. Bees provided the majority of visits to study species at all sites, and 33 of the 76 plants received more than 90% of their visits from bees. Furthermore, pollen deposition onto stigmas from single-visit events (SVD, a measure of pollination effectiveness) was significantly higher for bees than non-bees at all the four sites where a major proportion of the flora was sampled. Solitary bees, and also bumblebees in temperate habitats, were the best potential pollinators for most plants in this respect, and significantly out-performed honeybees. Only a few plants were well served by bombyliid flies, and fewer again by larger hoverflies, butterflies, or solitary wasps. Bees also achieved better matches of their visit timing to peak pollen availability (measured indirectly as peak SVD), and made much shorter visits to flowers than did non-bees, permitting a substantially greater visit frequency. Additionally, they deposited significantly lower levels of potentially deleterious heterospecific pollen on stigmas in heathland and Mediterranean garigue, though not in the UK garden with densely clustered high-diversity flowering, or in the Kenyan savanna site with particularly dispersed flowering patches and some specialist non-bee flowers. Our data provide a novel and quantified characterisation of the specific advantages of bees as flower visitors, and underline the need to conserve diverse bee communities.
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/f5e34c542f9955a8df4f8e0e06ed9f7d22ed66d1
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
Citations in the corpus
- Larger pollinators deposit more pollen on stigmas across multiple plant species—A meta‐analysis (2020, result): “We found that flies produced a smaller SVD than honey bees (within-group analysis) and wild bees (between-group analysis), a finding that agrees with Willmer et al. (2017) who found bee species deposited more pollen than fly species.”