ON T HE EMPIRICS OF FOREIGN A ID AND G ROWTH
By Carl-Johan Dalgaard, H. Hansen, F. Tarp. 2004
1,008 citations recorded by the source corpus.
The present paper re-examines the effectiveness of foreign aid theoretically and empirically. Using a standard OLG model we show that aid inflows will in general affect long-run productivity. The size and direction of the impact may depend on policies, ‘deep’ structural characteristics and the size of the inflow. The empirical analysis investigates these possibilities. Overall we find that aid has been effective in spurring growth, but the magnitude of the effect depends on climate-related circumstances. Finally, we argue that the Collier-Dollar allocation rule should be seriously reconsidered by donor agencies if aid effectiveness is related to climate. The usefulness of foreign aid in promoting growth in developing countries has been an area of controversy ever since Rosenstein-Rodan in 1943 advocated for aid to Eastern and South-Eastern Europe. Browsing through successive editions of a leading textbook in development economics provides a telling illustration of how the confidence in aid effectiveness dwindled over the years. In the first edition of ‘Leading Issues in Economic Development’, Meier (1964) dedicated a full 18-page section to the issue of foreign aid. He started out asking: ‘How much aid?’. By the time of the sixth edition (Meier, 1995), the treatment of foreign aid had been cut into half, and the questions in focus were ‘Why official assistance?’ and ‘Does aid work?’. In the 2000 edition (Meier and Rauch, 2000), ‘foreign aid’ is not even listed in the index. However, in the last few years the pendulum has swung, and a gradually forming consensus view has emerged that aid ‘works’. Indeed, panel-based empirical studies have repeatedly concluded that foreign aid does impact positively on growth. Nevertheless, controversy remains since it also seems clear from the data that foreign aid is far from equally effective everywhere. A key question is therefore what causes such differences in ‘the return to aid’? From a policy perspective, this issue is important as it ultimately influences the allocation of foreign aid across countries. Inspired by the work of Burnside and Dollar (2000) and Collier and Dollar (2001, 2002), which suggests that aid only works in places with ‘good’ policies, some donors are increasingly allocating aid to countries that perform well in terms of particular proxies for the policy environment. The motivation is clearly the desire to maximise the effectiveness of tax financed foreign assistance. However, if the variation in the effectiveness of aid on productivity is not policy induced but rather a result of other poor initial conditions a very different allocation rule would maximise the effect of aid donations on long-run productivity and poverty.
Subfields: Development, Economics and Econometrics, Safety Research
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/a070d0cfe88f3955cd8a783176cf05ab6d086b25
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Development
- Faisal Z. Ahmed
- E. Werker
- Charles Cohen
- Michael A. Clemens
- Samuel Bazzi
- S. Feeny
- M. McGillivray
- Matthew S. Winters
In Economics and Econometrics
- Michael A. Clemens
- Samuel Bazzi
- Faisal Z. Ahmed
- E. Werker
- Charles Cohen
- N. Hermes
- S. Feeny
- Robert Lensink
In Safety Research
- E. Werker
- Faisal Z. Ahmed
- Charles Cohen
- Matthew S. Winters
- N. Hermes
- Bichaka Fayissa
- Samuel Bazzi
- Philipp Harms
Citations in the corpus
- It Works; It Doesn't; It Can, But That Depends (2006, background): “Yes Aid is effective in improving quality of life in democratic countries Dalgaard et al. (2004) Yes Yes Yes Aid is effective with diminishing returns, is less effective in tropical regions and is independent from the policy environment Quadratic aid term is included in the growth model…”
- How Is Foreign Aid Spent? Evidence from a Natural Experiment (2009, background): “Other instruments incorporate the share of a recipient country's area in the tropics (Dalgaard et al, 2004) and whether the country is a " friend " of the U.S., France, OPEC etc. (Boone, 1996).”
- Making Progress on Foreign Aid (2015, background): “Svensson (2000) finds that foreign aid, like trade windfalls, increase corruption in a panel of 10Roodman (2007) focuses on Dollar & Burnside (2000), Collier & Dehn (2001), Collier & Dollar (2002), Collier & Hoeffler (2004), Hansen & Tarp (2001), Dalgaard et al (2004), Guillaumont & Chauvet (2001).”
- Trade openness, foreign aid and economic growth in post-liberalisation Ghana: An application of ARDL bounds test (2011, neutral): “…only in countries with good economic policies and institutional environment, others like Collier and Dehn (2001); Guillaumont and Chauvet (2001); Dalgaard et al. (2004) argues that foreign aid is rather effective conditional on countries with more vulnerable economic conditions and/or outside…”
- The Trouble with the MDGS: Confronting Expectations of Aid and Development Success (2007, critical): “The results of Burnside-Dollar appear to be somewhat fragile—changing the period, adding new country data, or altering the definitions of ‘‘aid’’ or ‘‘good policies’’ tend to weaken the results (Dalgaard et al., 2004; Easterly, Levine, & Roodman, 2003; Guillamont & Chauvet, 2001; Hansen & Tarp, 2001”
- Coming into Money: The Impact of Foreign Aid on Leader Survival (2010, background): “Regarding economic growth and stability, economists find that aid’s impact is highly conditional on domestic socioeconomic and climatic circumstances (Chenery and Strout 1966; Burnside and Dollar 2000, 2004; Dalgaard, Hansen, and Tarp 2004; Kosack and Tobin 2006).”
- Does Foreign Aid In Education Promote Economic Growth? Evidence From Sub-Saharan Africa (2014, background): “4 Furthermore, some studies have found that aid is less effective in countries that are located in the tropics (Dalgaard et al., 2004; Roodman, 2004).”
- The Politics of Effective Foreign Aid (2010, background): “…to economic growth, did not lead at all to economic growth, or led to economic growth conditional on other factors (Hansen & Tarp 2000; Hansen & Tarp 2001; Lensik & White 2001; Clemens et al. 2004; Dalgaard et al. 2004; Easterly et al. 2004; Roodman 2007, 2008b; Rajan & Subramanian 2008).”