Incompressible flow and the finite element method
By J. Szmelter. 2001
1,002 citations recorded by the source corpus.
It was with a rare pleasure that I read these books and I have already used them many times as handbooks. As the title indicates, the books are about incompressible flow and finite elements. However, it may be worth pointing out that the books are useful for a broader numerical methods audience. In parts of the books finite volume and finite difference discretizations are discussed and compared with finite elements. This is done in a way that should increase better understanding of these methods and could help in transferring knowledge between the different communities. Moreover, readers interested in compressible flows would benefit as well, since modelling of incompressible flows has automatically to address many aspects of compressible flow modelling. Throughout the books the authors reveal an in-depth understanding of the subject as well as an awareness of what has been done so far. This is not surprising, as they are very well known and respected among the finite element method community. What is most pleasing is that some subjects that are frequently explained by others in a somewhat unclear way, or avoided altogether, are specifically targeted and thoroughly explained in these books. They mention, for example, issues of consistent mass matrix and lumped matrix, or null spaces and choice of elements for pressure and velocity interpolations. There are many more items worth detailed reading. The discussion about ‘wiggles’, which expands on the frequently cited publication by P. M. Gresho and R. L. Lee ‘Don’t suppress the wiggles—they’re telling you something’, is especially educational and entertaining. In fact, the whole book is entertaining. The style is very informal and (in my opinion) enjoyable. There are jokes in the text and you will be urged to wake up if you do not perceive that the authors are in favour of Gallerkin methods. Of course, readers with a different sense of humour may find the style irritating. Nevertheless, the text is always very clear. In fact, many difficult issues are explained in a simple way, which in itself is a difficult thing to do. The books address most aspects of modelling incompressible, isothermal, laminar flow by the finite element method. In the first volume the advection–diffusion equation is studied as a vehicle to introduce an explanation for the methodologies provided later to solve the Navier– Stokes equations. The books are correctly addressed to readers with some background in CFD and FEM. For complete beginners there is a good list (with brief comments) of recommended textbooks, which should provide a start. The books are particularly suitable for PhD students with projects in relevant subjects. I found that to benefit most from the explanations, it is best to read it for the first time in sequential order. The books should also be very useful to more ‘seasoned’ researchers. They provide a very comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art. The references are very much up-to-date and well chosen. With a large number of papers being published in this field these books can save the reader time, since the key information is well selected, analysed and presented by the authors. The major trends of research are courteously commented on with more than average frankness. This may be of interest even to readers not sharing the authors’ preferences. As yet, on every attempt, I have been able to find in these books detailed information I needed. The paperback price of £80 for two volumes is reasonable. Only infrequently are such good textbooks published and therefore I would also recommend them as a good buy for research libraries. If the reader finds criticisms, these experienced authors have most probably apologized for them in the introduction. There seems to be every eventuality covered. There is also a promise to write a third volume to complete the picture.
Subfields: Computational Mechanics, Computational Theory and Mathematics, Fluid Flow and Transfer Processes
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/99b4eaf1bb5de30695394e929385fafa89f9af24
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Computational Mechanics
- Alfio Maria Quarteroni
- Andrea Manzoni
- Thomas J. R. Hughes
- Ming-Chen Hsu
- Gianluigi Rozza
- David J. Benson
- Yuri Bazilevs
- Michael A. Scott
In Computational Theory and Mathematics
- Thomas J. R. Hughes
- Yuri Bazilevs
- Gianluigi Rozza
- Ming-Chen Hsu
- David J. Benson
- Andrea Manzoni
- Alfio Maria Quarteroni
- Karen Veroy
In Fluid Flow and Transfer Processes
- Yuri Bazilevs
- Gianluigi Rozza
- Andrea Manzoni
- Ming-Chen Hsu
- Wolfgang Ehlers
- Jerrold E. Marsden
- Thomas J. R. Hughes
- Geoffrey C. Fox
Citations in the corpus
- Continental scale, high order, high spatial resolution, ice sheet modeling using the Ice Sheet System Model (ISSM) (2012, methodology): “[34] For the thermal model, P1 elements are used, combined with the Streamline Upwind Petrov-Galerkin (SUPG) [Gresho and Sani, 2000a] formulation to prevent potential numerical oscillations due to dominant advection terms.”
- On the causes of pressure oscillations in low‐permeable and low‐compressible porous media (2012, background): “Fortin, via [22]) Q2P− 1 Discontinuous, linear (rather than bilinear) pressure; “optimal” [11], “most accurate 2D element” [22] P1 P1 MINI [24] Q þþ 1 Q1 Quadrilateral MINI analogue [25] Elements of polynomial order k are classified as Pk or Qk for Lagrangian elements, while RTk, CRk, and TRk are th”
- Comparison of monolithic and splitting solution schemes for dynamic porous media problems (2009, methodology): “[38] for references) or the more pragmatic patch test for mixed formulations of Zienkiewicz et al.”
- Numerical error in groundwater flow and solute transport simulation (2003, background): “Mass lumping enables marginally faster calculation of the matrix equation and theoretically leads to a more stable system, but doubts have been raised about its validity and accuracy [Becker et al., 1986; Gresho and Sani, 1998].”
- Computational predictability of time‐dependent natural convection flows in enclosures (including a benchmark solution) (2002, methodology): “Additional information relevant to this problem may be found in References [2, 8–10].”
- Structure-preserving discretization of incompressible fluids (2009, methodology): “First and foremost, our work derives the fluid mechanics equations from the least action principle, while many previous techniques are based on finite volume, finite difference, or finite element methods applied to Euler equations(see [21, 40, 24] and references therein).”
- Numerical solution of parametrized Navier–Stokes equations by reduced basis methods (2007, methodology): “The numerical approximation of steady Navier-Stokes equations has been carried out by using a parametrized version of MLife, a FEM library (developed by F. Saleri at MOX) in Matlab-PDE toolbox environment where we have considered P2−P1 elements for velocity and pressure, respectively, over a triangu”
- On the stability of the reduced basis method for Stokes equations in parametrized domains (2007, background): “• b is related to the generalized eigenvalue problem (see [7,13,23]):”
- An efficient computational framework for reduced basis approximation and a posteriori error estimation of parametrized Navier–Stokes flows (2014, methodology): “by choosing V N×QN as the space of Taylor–Hood P2−P1 elements [11]; however, this choice is not restrictive – the whole construction keeps holding for other spaces combinations as well.”
- Neurobiology of Aging: Contents (2005, neutral): “The literature on numerical methods for incompressible flow problems is vast; see, e.g., Elman et al. (2005c), Fortin (1993), Glowinski (2003), Gresho and Sani (1998), Gunzburger (1989), Quarteroni and Valli (1994), Temam (1984), Turek (1999) and Wesseling (2001).”