Resolving society's energy trilemma through the Energy Justice Metric
By R. Heffron, D. McCauley, Benjamin Sovacool. 2015
352 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Carbon dioxide emissions continue to increase to the detriment of society in many forms. One of the difficulties faced is the imbalance between the competing aims of economics, politics and the environment which form the trilemma of energy policy. This article advances that this energy trilemma can be resolved through energy justice. Energy justice develops the debate on energy policy to one that highlights cosmopolitanism, progresses thinking beyond economics and incorporates a new futuristic perspective. To capture these dynamics of energy justice, this research developed an Energy Justice Metric (EJM) that involves the calculation of several metrics: (1) a country (national) EJM; (2) an EJM for different energy infrastructure; and (3) an EJM which is incorporated into economic models that derive costs for energy infrastructure projects. An EJM is modeled for China, the European Union and the United States, and for different energy infrastructure in the United Kingdom. The EJM is plotted on a Ternary Phase Diagram which is used in the sciences for analyzing the relationship (trilemma) of three forms of matter. The development of an EJM can provide a tool for decision-making on energy policy and one that solves the energy trilemma with a just and equitable approach.
Subfields: General Energy, Pollution, Renewable Energy, Sustainability and the Environment
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/9684583b129f51cac6fc8be0ba3c4bc18ed29041
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In General Energy
In Pollution
- Benjamin Sovacool
- Kirsten E. H. Jenkins
- D. McCauley
- Lucy Baker
- Mary-Kate Burns
- Niek Mouter
- Nicholas Hacking
- Matthew J. Burke
In Renewable Energy, Sustainability and the Environment
- Benjamin Sovacool
- Kirsten E. H. Jenkins
- D. McCauley
- Lucy Baker
- Matthew J. Burke
- H. Wlokas
- Chaitanya Kumar Kotikalapudi
- Mary-Kate Burns
Citations in the corpus
- The methodologies, geographies, and technologies of energy justice: a systematic and comprehensive review (2021, background): “30 Supporting jobs, technological and expertise trade Islar et al. (2017) “Thus, Nepalese policy-makers may choose to strengthen the local technological capacity, by supporting local grid-extension movements in NACEUN, but they may also cultivate geopolitical relations to China and India by agreeing”
- European energy poverty metrics: Scales, prospects and limits (2020, neutral): “There are other challenges e such as lack of political will by policymakers and implementers, and conditions that limit and inhibit public engagement e but the focus here is on metrics, as improvements on this front are claimed to serve as a basis for practical action (cf [3 e 5].”
- Energy justice at the end of the wire: Enacting community energy and equity in Wales (2017, neutral): “…to understand the complex trade-offs involved in the making of energy policy as expressed through the competing demands of energy security, energy equity and environmental sustainability – jointly known as the energy trilemma (Gunningham, 2013; World Energy Council, 2015; Heffron et al, 2015).”
- New frontiers and conceptual frameworks for energy justice (2017, background): “(28) Drawing from Heffron et al. (2015), can energy justice principles such as these be quantified and then measured in terms of performance?”
- Energy justice: a policy approach (2017, neutral): “…the Fukushima disaster can be seen to represent a change from the ‘morality of risk’ to the ‘morality of carbon reduction’, for example, removing the justice concerns of nuclear power and raising the challenges of widely distributed renewables and household affordability (Rehner and McCauley 2015).”
- Politicizing energy justice and energy system transitions: Fossil fuel divestment and a “just transition” (2017, neutral): “However, due to the implications of climate justice suggesting large-scale and structural changes to the socio-energy system, Heffron et al. (2015) contend that decision-makers find it difficult to relate it to the dominant discipline within policy formulation: namely, neoclassical economics, which…”