Optimal PI and PID control of first-order plus delay processes and evaluation of the original and improved SIMC rules

By C. Grimholt, Sigurd Skogestad. Journal of Process Control, 2018

117 citations recorded by the source corpus.

Abstract The first-order plus delay process model with parameters k (gain), τ (time constant) and θ (delay) is the most used representation of process dynamics. This paper has three objectives. First, we derive optimal PI- and PID-settings for this process. Optimality is here defined as the minimum Integrated Absolute Error (IAE) to disturbances for a given robustness level. The robustness level, which is here defined as the sensitivity peak (Ms), may be regarded as a tuning parameter. Second, we compare the optimal IAE-performance with the simple SIMC-rules, where the SIMC tuning parameter τc is adjusted to get a given robustness. The “original” SIMC-rules give a PI-controller for a first-order with delay process, and we find that this SIMC PI-controller is close to the optimal PI-controller for most values of the process parameters (k, τ, θ). The only exception is for delay-dominant processes where the SIMC-rule gives a pure integrating controller. The third objective of this paper is to propose and study a very simple modification to the original SIMC-rule, which is to add a derivative time τd = θ/3 (for the serial PID-form). This gives performance close to the IAE-optimal PID also for delay-dominant processes. We call this the “improved” SIMC-rule, but we put “improved” in quotes, because this controller requires more input usage, so in practice the original SIMC-rule, which gives a PI-controller, may be preferred.

Subfields: Control and Systems Engineering

View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/8bee7f2bf9e190de4208d112e9f7c6be0d7a9843