Industrial Clusters: Complexes, Agglomeration and/or Social Networks?
By Ian Richard Gordon, Philip McCann. Urban studies, 2000
1,421 citations recorded by the source corpus.
The concept of industrial clusters has attracted much attention during the past decade, both as descriptive of an increasingly important phenomenon and as a basis for effective public intervention in the economies of lagging city-regions. However, there is much ambiguity in the way in which this concept is used, presenting an obstacle both to empirical testing and to realistic assessments of policy relevance. In this paper, we distinguish three ideal-typical models of processes which may underlie spatial concentrations of related activities, with very different implications both in terms of relevant evidence and the scope for promotional policies. Survey data for the London conurbation are used to explore the relation between concentration and different forms of linkage, with results which point to the dominance of pure agglomeration effects in this context at least.
Subfields: Economics and Econometrics, Urban Studies
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/7d7dc43fa465754fd72db23952aa7abcaeaac709
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Economics and Econometrics
- Ron A. Boschma
- A. Rodríguez‐Pose
- Henry S. C. Yeung
- H. Bathelt
- Philip McCann
- Michaela Trippl
- Ron Martin
- P. Sunley
In Urban Studies
- A. Rodríguez‐Pose
- P. Sunley
- H. Bathelt
- Philip McCann
- S. Iammarino
- P. Morosini
- R. Fitjar
- Alessandra Faggian
Citations in the corpus
- New Challenges for Urban Governance (2000, background): “In the absence of suf cient knowledge, there is a danger that policy-makers assume that one model provides a suf cient solution to the spatial organisation of activity, most recently economic cluster theory (Bennett et al., 1999; Gordon and McCann, 2000; Simmie and Sennett, 1999).”
- Agglomeration, clusters, and industrial policy (2013, background): “The first, well-documented problem is one of definition (Gordon and McCann, 2000; Martin and Sunley, 2003; Duranton, 2011).”
- Creative clusters and city growth (2008, background): “Questions have been raised regarding the relative importance of local linkages (Wolfe and Gertler 2004; Simmie 2004), and whether agglomeration rather than clustering is more likely to be a reflection of urban economies (Gordan and McCann 2000; Wolfe and Gertler 2004).”
- Analytical Differences in the Economics of Geography: The Case of the Multinational Firm (2005, background): “5 Analytical typologies of clusters If we adopt a transactions-costs perspective we can define three distinct types of industrial clusters, according to the nature of firms in the clusters, and the nature of their relations and transactions within the cluster ( Gordon and McCann, 2000; McCann and S”
- Regional clusters in Germany--their geography and their relevance for entrepreneurial activities (2004, background): “• Based upon the argument of the ‘industrial complex model’ referring to explicit links of sales and purchases between firms (Gordon & McCann, 2000), we know that the local/re- gional market and customers are decisive for many start-ups during the first months and years.”
- Explaining Firm Employment Growth: Does Location Matter? (2004, background): “distinction can be made between externalities that occur as a result of clustering of similar economic activities (also referred to as ‘localisation economies’) and externalities that are related to the clustering of a large range of different activities (‘urbanisation economies’) ( Gordon and McCan”
- Introduction: Clusters in Urban and Regional Development (2004, background): “These findings, Simmie suggests, undermine notions of dynamic localised clusters at the heart of the knowledge economy, leading him to conclude that agglomeration is more likely to reflect more conventional urbanisation economies (Gordon and McCann, 2000).”
- Clusters and knowledge: local buzz, global pipelines and the process of knowledge creation (2004, background): “…and ‘untraded interdependencies’, it has been shown that socio-institutional settings, interfirm communication and interactive processes of localised learning play decisive roles in processes of innovation and growth (Maskell et al. 1998, Gordon and McCann 2000, Bathelt and Glückler 2002).”
- Deconstructing clusters: chaotic concept or policy panacea? (2003, background): “In response to this shortcoming, Gordon and McCann (2000), argue for distinguishing three main cluster models (theories).”
- When Local Interaction Does Not Suffice: Sources of Firm Innovation in Urban Norway (2011, positive): “…same or in related sectors and located in close geographical proximity can give rise to the interactions, networks, and institutional settings at the heart of the generation and diffusion of tacit knowledge and, ultimately, the spread of innovation (Gordon and McCann, 2000; Maskell et al, 1998).”
- Buzz: face-to-face contact and the urban economy (2004, background): “To begin with, there is widespread agreement that localized backward and forward linkages, while important in specific cases, can account for only a small part of contemporary urbanization (Gordon and McCann, 2000).”
- Firm innovation: The influence of R&D cooperation and the geography of human capital inputs (2008, neutral): “JEL classification: O310; J600; R300 Keywords: Innovation; Labor; Mobility; R&D; Cooperation”
- Industrial Clusters, Knowledge Integration and Performance (2004, methodology): “…and managerial-innovation advantages Romagnoli and Lungarella (1989) III––Economic linkages Common customers (both firms and individuals) Cheshire and Gordon (1995), Gordon and McCann (2000) European Commission (1999) Lazerson (1990) Humphrey and Schmitz (1998), Rabellotti (1995) Meyer-Stamer…”