Are Ideas Getting Harder to Find?
By Nicholas Bloom, Chad Jones, John Van Reenen, Michael Webb. 2020
979 citations recorded by the source corpus.
Long-run growth in many models is the product of two terms: the effective number of researchers and their research productivity. We present evidence from various industries, products, and firms showing that research effort is rising substantially while research productivity is declining sharply. A good example is Moore’s Law. The number of researchers required today to achieve the famous doubling of computer chip density is more than 18 times larger than the number required in the early 1970s. More generally, everywhere we look we find that ideas, and the exponential growth they imply, are getting harder to find. (JEL D24, E23, O31, O47)
Subfields: Economics and Econometrics, Management Science and Operations Research, Economics & Operations Research
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Economics and Econometrics
- Ufuk Akcigit
- S. Ateş
- M. D. Ridder
- Philippe Aghion
- Ajay Agrawal
- Antonin Bergeaud
- Avi Goldfarb
- Pete Klenow
In Management Science and Operations Research
- Ajay Agrawal
- S. Ateş
- Ufuk Akcigit
- Anders Søgaard
- Ivan Vulic
- Philippe Aghion
- Sebastian Ruder
- Tom B. Brown
In Economics & Operations Research
- S. Ateş
- Ufuk Akcigit
- Philippe Aghion
- Allan Dafoe
- Tom B. Brown
- Avi Goldfarb
- Joshua S. Gans
- Ajay Agrawal
Citations in the corpus
- Measuring the Algorithmic Efficiency of Neural Networks (2020, background): “[Bloom et al., 2017] looks into the relationship between scientific progress and spending: In many models, economic growth arises from people creating ideas, and the long-run growth rate is the product of two terms: the effective number of researchers and their research productivity...”
- Market Power and Innovation in the Intangible Economy (2019, background): “Brynjolfsson et al. (2018) claim that artificial intelligence is a new General Purpose Technology that initially requires firms to invest in unmeasured intangible capital, causing measured productivity growth to decline but eventually increase. This does not, however, explain the coincidental reduct”
- The COVID‐19 Pandemic and Its Impact on the Global Economy: What Does It Take to Turn Crisis into Opportunity? (2020, background): “Bloom et al. (2020) find that research productivity is falling sharply.”
- Artificial Intelligence, Automation, and Work (2018, neutral): “First, we may be running out of good ideas to create new jobs, sectors, and products capable of expanding the demand for labor (e.g., Gordon 2016; Bloom et al. 2017), even if automation continues at a healthy or accelerating pace.”
- Economic Policy for Artificial Intelligence (2018, background): “Put differently, recent empirical work suggests that scientific ideas may be getting harder to find (Bloom et al. 2017).”
- The Offense-Defense Balance of Scientific Knowledge: Does Publishing AI Research Reduce Misuse? (2019, background): “ity (of which there is a constant supply) than to make a scientific discovery (see [3]).”
- Square One Bias in NLP: Towards a Multi-Dimensional Exploration of the Research Manifold (2022, background): “This paper can be seen in the line of other meta-research (Davis, 1971; Lakatos, 1976; Weber, 2006; Bloom et al., 2020) that seeks to analyze research practices and whether a scientific field is heading in the right direction.”
- AI and the Economy (2018, neutral): “Moreover, Bloom, Jones, et al. (2017) document the many domains in which ideas are getting harder to find—that is, larger research inputs are needed to produce additional productivity outputs.”
- De-Globalisation? Global Value Chains in the Post-COVID-19 Age (2020, neutral): “Similarly, it is also important to point out that the amount of R&D spending required to sustain Moore’s Law is much higher today than it was in the 1970s and 1980s (see Bloom et al., 2020).”
- What Happened to US Business Dynamism? (2019, background): “…rate (Eggertsson, Robbins, andWold 2018; Liu, Mian, and Sufi 2022), a decline in research productivity (implying that ideas are getting harder to find; Gordon 2016; Bloom et al. 2017), and a decline in workers’ market power relative to employers’ (Bivens et al. 2014; Naidu, Posner, and Weyl 2018).”
- Missing Growth from Creative Destruction (2017, background): “First, it means that ideas are not getting as hard to find as official statistics suggest, with implications for the production of ideas and future growth (Gordon, 2012; Bloom et al., 2016).”