Validation of a Three-Point Gait-Scoring System for Field Assessment of Walking Ability of Commercial Broilers
By A. Webster, B. Fairchild, T. Cummings, P. Stayer. 2008
70 citations recorded by the source corpus.
ABSTRACT A 3-point gait-scoring system used to evaluate broiler walking ability in welfare audits of commercial flocks in the United States was compared with the 6-point Kestin system. In 2 university trials, market-age broilers of 2 commercial varieties were gait-scored by 2 observers for each scoring system. Subsamples of birds were rescored and evaluated in latency-to-lie (LTL) tests. Too few birds had significant walking difficulties in these trials to allow for a good comparison of the 2 scoring systems across all the gait score categories, but the data were encouraging despite sampling limitations. There was a significant association between the 2 systems, and both had substantial between-observer agreement. Both scoring systems had significant correlations with LTL, but the variation of LTL was too high to give gait score or LTL much predictive value for each other. In the field observations, 2 teams of observers scored broilers 47 to 61 d of age on 5 commercial farms each. Two pairs of observers on each team scored the same birds, each pair using the 3-point system or the Kestin system. Broilers with walking problems were oversampled to obtain an adequate number in each gait score category. Weighted κ statistics showed substantial between-observer agreement in each system but more so in the 3-point system, suggesting that the application of the 3-point system was more consistent between observers. Spearman correlations between 3-point and Kestin scores for individual birds indicated good correspondence between the 2 systems. The simplicity of the 3-point gait-scoring system appears to facilitate between-observer agreement, making it preferable to more complex systems for use in commercial animal welfare audits. The correspondence between the gait-scoring systems validates the 3-point system in light of the 6-point Kestin system.
Subfields: Animal Science and Zoology, Small Animals
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/75e14cae444e3c12c8019cc9b26298d116234a20
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Animal Science and Zoology
In Small Animals
Citations in the corpus
- In search of the behavioural correlates of optical flow patterns in the automated assessment of broiler chicken welfare (2013, methodology): “s a validation of this data, a second observer used a 3oint score (Dawkins et al., 2004; Webster et al., 2008) nd gait scored a total of 100 individuals on days 32–34.”
- Optical flow, flock behaviour and chicken welfare (2012, methodology): “As a validation of these data, a second observer used a 3-point score (Dawkins et al. 2004; Webster et al. 2008) and gait scored a total of 100 individuals on days 32e34.”
- Optical flow patterns in broiler chicken flocks as automated measures of behaviour and gait (2009, methodology): “…and physically demanding if done correctly, the results vary with the person doing the scoring even after training (Butterworth et al., 2007; Webster et al., 2008) and it gives only a ‘snapshot’ of the welfare state of a flock so that it is often only done as a maximum once or twice for…”