The repeatability of behaviour: a meta-analysis
By A. Bell, S. Hankison, K. Laskowski. Animal Behaviour, 2009
2,023 citations recorded by the source corpus.
There is increasing interest in individual differences in animal behaviour. Recent research now suggests that an individual’s behaviour, once considered to be plastic, may be more predictable than previously thought. Here, we take advantage of the large number of studies that have estimated the repeatability of various behaviours to evaluate whether there is good evidence for consistent individual differences in behaviour and to answer some outstanding questions about possible factors that can influence repeatability. Specifically, we use meta-analysis to ask whether different types of behaviours were more repeatable than others, and if repeatability estimates depended on taxa, sex, age, field versus laboratory, the number of measures and the interval between measures. Some of the overall patterns that were revealed by this analysis were that repeatability estimates were higher in the field compared to the laboratory and repeatability was higher when the interval between observations was short. Mate preference behaviour was one of the best studied but least repeatable behaviours. Our findings prompt new insights into the relative flexibility of different types of behaviour and offer suggestions for the design and analysis of future research.
Subfields: Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics, Small Animals
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/424f9d79fb55608c5582802cf97097c2dcc8ecc0
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics
- L. Garamszegi
- N. Dingemanse
- Andrew Sih
- J. Stamps
- P. Biro
- Alexander D. M. Wilson
- Shinichi Nakagawa
- Daniel T. Blumstein
In Small Animals
- J. Stamps
- N. Dingemanse
- Ton G. G. Groothuis
- Alexander D. M. Wilson
- J. Godin
- P. Biro
- Andrew Sih
- Daniel T. Blumstein
Citations in the corpus
- Individual behavioural consistency and plasticity in an urban spider (2012, positive): “However, high behavioural plasticity may not always be possible, as evidence is accumulating that many animals exhibit personalities (i.e. consistent interindividual differences in behaviours over time and across contexts; Groothuis & Carere 2005; Bell et al. 2009).”
- Covariation between personalities and individual differences in coping with stress: Converging evidence and hypotheses (2010, background): “…challenges (Broom, 2001) or otherwise stressful situations, e.g. exploring a novel environment (Drent et al., 2003) or suffering social defeat by a conspecific (Koolhaas et al. 1999; Carere et al., 2001; reviews by Sih et al., 2004a,b; Carere and Eens 2005; Réale et al., 2007; Bell et al., 2009).”
- Individual repeatability in timing and spatial flexibility of migration routes of trans-Saharan migratory raptors (2014, background): “The observed high repeatability in the timing of both spring and autumn migration supports the existence of individually optimized migration schedules (Battley, 2006; Bell et al., 2009; Vardanis et al., 2011).”
- Development of boldness and docility in yellow-bellied marmots (2013, background): “Time between trials was included to control for potential biases in repeatability (Bell et al. 2009).”
- Linking levels of personality: personalities of the ‘average’ and ‘most extreme’ group members predict colony-level personality (2013, background): “colony-level finding resembles those observed in individual organisms (Bell et al. 2009) and might reflect differences in colony age, because naturally occurring colonies generally had larger, more elaborate web architectures.”
- How does temperature affect behaviour? Multilevel analysis of plasticity, personality and predictability in hermit crabs (2013, background): “…when animals have a particular behavioural tendency (consistency over time or across situations) they are still rather unpredictable, as evidenced by a recent cross-taxon metaanalysis showing that, on average, most behavioural variation resides at the within-individual level (Bell et al. 2009).”
- Network position: a key component in the characterization of social personality types (2012, background): “Such between-individual variation has been demonstrated for a wide variety of behaviours (e.g. boldness, activity, aggression and sociability) (Bell et al. 2009).”
- Collective personalities in honeybee colonies are linked to colony fitness (2011, background): “…also display consistent, heritable differences in personality traits such as boldness, tendency to explore and aggressiveness (Wilson 1998; Gosling 2001; Bell et al. 2009) and that these traits can be linked to survival and reproductive success (Dingemanse & Réale 2005; Smith & Blumstein 2008).”
- Social personality traits in chimpanzees: temporal stability and structure of behaviourally assessed personality traits in three captive populations (2011, neutral): “93, which is within the values reported for most animal species (Bell et al. 2009).”
- Shy trout grow faster: exploring links between personality and fitness-related traits in the wild (2011, positive): “Differences in exploration tendency and aggressiveness were consistent over trials, and repeatability measures were within the range of observed in other species (Table 2, Bell et al. 2009).”