Yield gap analysis with local to global relevance—A review
By Martin K. van Ittersum, K. Cassman, P. Grassini, J. Wolf, P. Tittonell, Zvi Hochman. 2013
1,521 citations recorded by the source corpus.
a b s t r a c t Yields of crops must increase substantially over the coming decades to keep pace with global food demand driven by population and income growth. Ultimately global food production capacity will be limited by the amount of land and water resources available and suitable for crop production, and by biophysical limits on crop growth. Quantifying food production capacity on every hectare of current farmland in a consistent and transparent manner is needed to inform decisions on policy, research, development and investment that aim to affect future crop yield and land use, and to inform on-ground action by local farmers through their knowledge networks. Crop production capacity can be evaluated by estimat- ing potential yield and water-limited yield levels as benchmarks for crop production under, respectively, irrigated and rainfed conditions. The differences between these theoretical yield levels and actual farmers' yields define the yield gaps, and precise spatially explicit knowledge about these yield gaps is essential to guide sustainable intensification of agriculture. This paper reviews methods to estimate yield gaps, with a focus on the local-to-global relevance of outcomes. Empirical methods estimate yield potential from 90 to 95th percentiles of farmers' yields, maximum yields from experiment stations, growers' yield contests or boundary functions; these are compared with crop simulation of potential or water-limited yields. Comparisons utilize detailed data sets from western Kenya, Nebraska (USA) and Victoria (Australia). We then review global studies, often performed by non-agricultural scientists, aimed at yield and sometimes yield gap assessment and compare several studies in terms of outcomes for regions in Nebraska, Kenya and The Netherlands. Based on our review we recommend key components for a yield gap assessment that can be applied at local to global scales. Given lack of data for some regions, the protocol recom- mends use of a tiered approach with preferred use of crop growth simulation models applied to relatively homogenous climate zones for which measured weather data are available. Within such zones simula- tions are performed for the dominant soils and cropping systems considering current spatial distribution of crops. Need for accurate agronomic and current yield data together with calibrated and validated crop models and upscaling methods is emphasized. The bottom-up application of this global protocol allows verification of estimated yield gaps with on-farm data and experiments. © 2012 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Subfields: Environmental Engineering, General Agricultural and Biological Sciences, Management Science and Operations Research
View Paper: https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/363b54545f1ea211bf79ddf6f68bc78050cd522c
How researchers see this paper
The researchers whose trusted networks rank it highest, strongest advocate first. Every researcher gets a different order.
In Environmental Engineering
- K. Cassman
- Paolo D'Odorico
- Martin K. van Ittersum
- Alberto Stanislao Atzori
- L. Rosa
- Benjamin L Turner
- H. Menendez
- R. Gates
In General Agricultural and Biological Sciences
- K. Cassman
- Paolo D'Odorico
- Martin K. van Ittersum
- H. Meijl
- Maria Cristina Rulli
- L. Rosa
- Andrzej Tabeau
- James R. Hunt
In Management Science and Operations Research
- K. Cassman
- Paolo D'Odorico
- Martin K. van Ittersum
- Alberto Stanislao Atzori
- Benjamin L Turner
- H. Menendez
- R. Gates
- Scott C. Chapman
Citations in the corpus
- Closing maize yield gaps in sub-Saharan Africa will boost soil N2O emissions (2020, background): “org, see Supplementary Table 2 for a list of used stations) [7,44].”
- System dynamics modeling for agricultural and natural resource management issues: Review of some past cases and forecasting future roles (2016, background): “As global populations continue to grow and more land becomes devoted to agriculture, agricultural production will have to be sustained on lands and soils traditionally not rated for intensive or long-term cultivation [11,16,17,19], creating elevated risk of soil erosion and other environmental exter”
- Can sub-Saharan Africa feed itself? (2016, methodology): “Cereal production in SSA is largely rainfed; hence, we use the water-limited yield potential as a benchmark for estimating yield gaps except for irrigated areas (mainly rice growing areas) where yield potential is unconstrained by water limitation (26).”
- Yield Gap and Production Gap of Rainfed Winter Wheat in the Southern Great Plains (2014, background): “Frontier yield functions relating grain yield to GSRF have been considered a reliable approach for estimating attainable yield across a wide range of environments (van Ittersum et al., 2013).”
- Global food self-sufficiency in the 21st century under sustainable intensification of agriculture (2020, background): “Importantly, narrowing yields gaps—the difference between biophysical potential yield and current yield (Lobell et al 2009, Van Ittersum et al 2013)—in underperforming croplands will enhance food self-sufficiency in developing countries where almost all the increase in food demand will come from…”
- Yield gap analysis of field crops: Methods and case studies (2015, methodology): “Van Wart et al. (2013) compared three gridded weather databases (CRU, NCEP/DOE, and NASA POWER data) for simulation of water-limited maize yields in four loca- FIGURE 15 Simulated rainfed maize water-limited yield (yw) across four sites in the uSA Corn using weather data from (a) NOAA weather…”